November 21  |  Our Communities

19 Fort Collins Etsy Shops We Love | Etsy Holiday Gift Guide

Finding the perfect gift can be tough — especially when you have to find something for your significant other, your best friend, your mom and your dog. Luckily, Etsy exists and is coming to the rescue again! This online shop is the best place to find one of a kind items, while still supporting small businesses.

To make your shopping experience even easier, we compiled a list of our favorite Fort Collins Etsy stores. Support local this year by shopping these creators from just around the corner. Grab a gift for your husband, your wife, your kids, your cat and even your home. Happy shopping!


For Him

Emerger Fly Fishing

Fort Collins Etsy Gift Guide

Photos courtesy of Emerger Fly Fishing

Chris Freeman believes fly anglers should have gear that is as classic, artistic and as rugged as the craft they pursue. To provide high-quality goods, he crafts every single waxed canvas bag by hand — ensuring quality because he is in control of the whole process. And as a fly fisherman himself, he tests his products right here in Northern Colorado! You find his products on Etsy and on his website


Small Business Saturday Fort Collins

Photos courtesy of Akinz / Brianne Janae Photography

Akinz is one of our favorite Fort Collins brick and mortar shops, and they also sell a few of their hand knitted and printed hats and shirts on Etsy. Now anyone in America and Europe can share the culture of Northern Colorado! Inspired by the beauty of our surroundings, Akinz offers products that help us celebrate nature and motivate us to get outside.

The Chic Shop Co.

Fort Collins Etsy Gift Guide

Photos courtesy of The Chic Shop Co. 

The Chic Shop Co. has products for everyone — even your home — but we especially love their custom printed hats! With a little sass, a bit of inspiration or Colorado pride, they have something for everyone and every head.

Lost Leather Works

The products from Lost Leather Works are all handmade right here in Fort Collins. With a rustic and modern key fob, leather bracelet, card holder or wallet, you can increase style and functionality for the man in your life!

Pretty Prairie Designs

Fort Collins Etsy Gift Guide

Photos courtesy of Pretty Prairie Designs

Pretty Prairie Designs has a whole section of personalized gifts for men. Their collar stays, guitar picks, money clips, bottle openers and fishing lures can all be stamped with your message. Check out their jewelry and other hand stamped mementos for everyone in your family!


For Her


Fort Collins Etsy Gift Guide

Photos courtesy of Hipstaflair

Your one-stop-shop for Fort Collins and Loveland gear, Hipstaflair has creative t-shirts for men and women. We especially love the ladies long sleeves. With their off the shoulder cut, you can be chic and NoCo proud at the same time!

Jane E Roberti

Fort Collins Etsy Gift Guide

Photos courtesy of Jane E Roberti

Owner and creator Jane E Roberti merges metal, leather, gems and wood to offer some of the most unique jewelry for men and women. The modern and earthy look is perfect for Northern Colorado style!

August Ink

Fort Collins Etsy Gift Guide

Photos courtesy of August Ink / Kelli Kroneberger / Becky Young

Perfect for the adventurer, the momma, and the daydreamer in your life, August Ink prints adorable shirts, hoodies and tote bags. You can show your love of camping, Colorado sunshine and even encourage kindness with a simple, fashionable gift.

Galactic Gaia Studios

Fort Collins Etsy Gift Guide

Photos courtesy of Galactic Gaia Studios

Brie Chesley makes the best jewelry for all your boho loving friends. Her arrowheads, feathers and dreamcatcher shapes are one of a kind. And mixed metals, colors and textures ensure you’ll be able to add style to any outfit!

Juno and Jupiter

Fort Collins Etsy Gift Guide

Photos courtesy of Juno and Jupiter / Katharine Claypool 

The made-to-order scarves and knit hats at Juno and Jupiter are so cozy! Perfect for the holidays, you can give the gift of warmth this Christmas and support a Fort Collins maker.


For the Kids

Cotton Serenity

Fort Collins Etsy Gift Guide

Photos courtesy of Cotton Serenity

Amanda Clark at Cotton Serenity creates custom nursery bedding and blankets to swaddle your baby the coziest way possible — in fur! We’re obsessed with the deer graphic and fur combo. It’s perfect for a woodland themed bedroom.

The Hat and I

Fort Collins Etsy Gift Guide

Photos courtesy of The Hat and I

Whether you’re looking for something cute, unique, fun, or a combination of all three, The Hat and I has it. They sell charming patterns so you can make a gift by hand! Your child can be the most stylish (and warm) kid on the block with a hand knitted head band, hat or dragon hood.

Honest Elements

Fort Collins Etsy Gift Guide

Photos courtesy of Honest Elements

Honest Elements offers modern and stylish graphic tees for babies and kids. Not only can your child be adorable (and coffee themed), they can be green, too! The materials at Honest Elements are made from organic and sustainable fabrics and screen printed with eco-friendly inks.

Mauka Woodwerks

Fort Collins Etsy Gift Guide

Photos courtesy of Mauka Woodwerks

Bob, the woodworking expert, and Deb, the educator, have been making toys and furniture as a hobby since 1977. On Valentine’s Day 2010, they created Mauka Woodwerks LLC. and started sharing their work with all of us. Their vintage inspired toys are educational and fun for various ages.


For the Pets

Rangers Bakery

Fort Collins Etsy Gift Guide

Photos courtesy of Rangers Bakery

Rangers Bakery makes organic dog treats out of Fort Collins. They even have seasonal recipes so your pet can get in the holiday spirit! You can fill their stocking with dog houses, bones and even empanada-shaped cookies.

Mountain Trail Leather

Fort Collins Etsy Gift Guide

Photos courtesy of Mountain Trail Leather

Mountain Trail Leather offers stylish and functional leather collars and leashes in different styles. Owner Tarah uses these products for her own Australian Shepherds and makes each item with strength, beauty and longevity in mind.

Incredible Cat

Fort Collins Etsy Gift Guide

Photos courtesy of Incredible Cat / Laura Martinson

Through Incredible Cat, Laura and Greg build cat beds, custom cat perches and designer cat trees right in their Fort Collins workshop. Made with high quality materials and furs, their furniture is some of the most durable on the market. Give your furry friend some luxury this holiday!


For the Home

Bear Mountain Metal Art

Fort Collins Etsy Gift Guide

Photos courtesy of Bear Mountain Metal Art

Bobby moved to Colorado three years ago hoping to start a business and live the dream surrounded by nature, and his art is inspired by the scenery and wildlife around us in Fort Collins. You can celebrate it too with a nature-inspired piece or a custom sign!

Blue Ridge Log Works

Fort Collins Etsy Gift Guide

Photos courtesy of Blue Ridge Log Works

Bill House and Greg Gardner named their furniture company after Blue Ridge Mountain, a favorite camping and hiking spot near Grand Lake. Their crafted furniture is the perfect way to design your home in classic Colorado lodge style with everything from tables to dog beds!


Spread the Cheer this Holiday

Which Etsy shops did you fall in love with? Share your gift ideas with us and help spread the holiday spirit this season.

And if we missed your favorite local Etsy store, let us know!

Posted InOur CommunitiesUnder, , , , , , , ,

Never Miss a Post!

We write about local events & home inspiration.

Looking for Your Dream Home?

Search real estate in Northern Colorado.

Leave a Comment